Cicero Family Dental
At Cicero Family Dental, our mission is to provide quality and affordable dental care for the entire family. We are dedicated to keeping our patients well-informed about their oral health and treatment options, ensuring they are in caring and competent hands.
We are accepting new patients and would love the opportunity to care for you and your loved ones. Our team is committed to creating a comfortable and relaxing environment, helping to alleviate the anxiety often associated with dental visits.
We offer a comprehensive range of services, from cleanings and preventive care to more complex treatments such as orthodontics, dental implants, and root canal therapy. We pride ourselves on educating our patients about dental health and providing them with the tools they need to maintain a healthy smile at home.
Led by Dr. Doug Hartley, a passionate advocate for dental health, we ensure that every treatment is delivered with the highest quality of care. Our facility is equipped with the latest technology, and our services are tailored to meet the unique needs of each patient.
Visit us at 411 N Peru St, Cicero, IN 46034, or call us at (317) 984-3531 to schedule your appointment. We are here to help!
Opening hours
- sunday: (closed)
- monday: (closed)
- tuesday: 8h-17h
- wednesday: 8h-17h
- thursday: 8h-17h
- friday: 7h-14h
- saturday: (closed)
Photos of Cicero Family Dental
Our comment from Best Dentists Club about Cicero Family Dental:
A Welcoming Environment Where Families Feel at Home
At Cicero Family Dental, the practice cultivates an atmosphere that goes far beyond a standard clinical setting. Visitors consistently note that from the moment they step through the door, the team greets them with genuine warmth and personal attention. Guided by Dr. Doug Hartley, the practice has built a strong reputation for treating every individual and family member as a valued part of a larger community. This family-oriented philosophy ensures that appointments are relaxed, conversational, and tailored to each patient's unique schedule.
Comprehensive Dental Services Supported by Modern Technology
The clinic provides a broad spectrum of dental care designed to maintain and restore oral health across all age groups. Patients regularly praise the seamless combination of preventive maintenance, restorative procedures, and specialized treatments. The practice leverages contemporary equipment and digital imaging to support accurate diagnoses and efficient care plans.
- Preventive cleanings and routine oral health assessments
- Orthodontic solutions and alignment treatments
- Dental implant placement and restorative procedures
- Endodontic therapy and complex root treatments
- Restorative dentistry, including crowns, fillings, and extractions
By integrating advanced techniques with a customized approach, the team ensures that each treatment plan aligns with the patient's long-term wellness goals.
Compassionate Care for Patients with Dental Anxiety
One of the most frequently highlighted strengths is the clinic's exceptional ability to put nervous patients at ease. Many reviewers mention that they previously avoided dental visits due to fear or past discomfort, yet found the experience here to be remarkably gentle and stress-free. The practitioners take the time to explain every step before and during procedures, use careful numbing techniques to minimize discomfort, and consistently check in to ensure relaxation throughout the appointment.
- Patient-centered communication that eliminates uncertainty
- Gentle techniques tailored for sensitive gums and anxious mouths
- Step-by-step explanations that demystify clinical procedures
- A judgment-free space where concerns are openly addressed
This thoughtful approach has earned the practice widespread praise for transforming dental visits from a source of stress into a comfortable, manageable routine.
Efficient Scheduling and Transparent Communication
Beyond clinical expertise, the administrative and clinical teams are consistently commended for their organizational efficiency and straightforward billing practices. Patients appreciate the clinic's ability to accommodate same-day requests for urgent concerns, coordinate multi-patient appointments for families, and navigate insurance benefits with clarity. The front desk and clinical assistants are noted for their punctuality, thoroughness, and proactive updates regarding treatment timelines and costs.
By maintaining clear financial expectations and prioritizing timely care, the practice reinforces patient trust and long-term loyalty.
Consistently Highly Rated by Local Families
Over many years, Cicero Family Dental has maintained an exceptional track record reflected in the steady flow of positive patient feedback. Long-term visitors frequently highlight the continuity of care, the dedication of hygienists and dental assistants, and the seamless collaboration among all team members. Patients consistently describe the practice as thorough, honest, and deeply committed to preserving natural smiles without unnecessary interventions. This consistent dedication to patient satisfaction continues to make the clinic a trusted choice for families in the region.
Services and Treatments
Cicero Family Dental: Reviews
Reviews are the opinions of their authors. We do not verify that the author was a customer.
Reviews on Google
4,9 out of 5 from 274 reviews
Fantastic experience: My hygienist, Jennifer was wonderful. Such a nice office and friendly staff. Highly recommend.
Fantastic experience: I would like to say I absolutely love this dentist office. My hygienist is awesome! Dr. Doug is great and the reception girl is remarkable. They make you feel like family! So convenient to get to. I can't say enough about Cicero family Dental.
Fantastic experience: All of the staff were super friendly and welcoming, and explained benefits/procedures really well. My daughter enjoyed learning every step of the way during her visit. Dr. Hartley was efficient and kind. A shoutout to Jennifer for being super sweet to both of my kids and for all the information throughout the visit. We are so happy to have found this awesome dental office!
Fantastic experience: Wonderful care. Got me in to check for a diagnostic xray on my tooth and left with a plan to correct the issues. Awesome staff and dentist. Highly recommend.
Fantastic experience: Dr. Hartley and Krystal were absolutely great!! Krystal made sure to explain everything that was being done and had a smile the entire time. Dr. Hartley was kind and helped me understand my options thoroughly.
Fantastic experience: My name is Daniel and I have to say this dental office is the best, most family friendly practice I've ever seen. Taking my x-rays was made easy by Chris and Amanda. They were super friendly, professional and pleasant and funny and joy to talk to. Dr. Doug is very professional and competent. Very happy with the experience. Update: 7/09/26 - My daughter Kate had her first dental visit today, and had a very pleasant time watching the bird feeder during her cleaning, and she agrees with me. We are sticking with Dr. Doug & his entire team! Thank You, Cicero Family Dental.
Fantastic experience: Very kind, thorough and efficient staff! Hygienist are very helpful and professional. Dr. Hartley is an excellent dentist and explains procedures so the patient can understand! Highly recommend this office.
Fantastic experience: Great third visit. They are very efficient and I enjoyed every interaction with all of the office staff. I do not like dentists. I've been through a lot of work. I loved the Techs and the Doc. Good people. Looking forward to going back. Take the time and look at all the reviews. Not getting an appointment, when you want it, is not a reason to give a bad review. If they are booked full, there's a reason, people love the dentist and their people.
Fantastic experience: I don’t like going to the dentist…. That being said, I have found that this dentist and his assistants have done their finest at making me comfortable and they are doing a great job at bringing my smile and trust in dentistry once again.
Fantastic experience: We love this practice! Everyone is so kind and personable, and responsive to any issue. I had a temporary crown come off and they got me in immediately. Very grateful for Dr Doug and his team!
Fantastic experience: Couldn’t ask for a better experience. Thank you … to all Cicero Family Dental awesome staff!!! They make a dental visit so enjoyable !!!
Fantastic experience: Great dentist. Easy to work with. Been going there for years.
Fantastic experience: They’re very friendly treats you like Family and very efficient they let you know what’s going on and figure out A treatment that will work for you
Fantastic experience: Amazing! I don't think one could expect a better dentist visit experience. My mouth is super sensitive. Not all dentist offices treat this the same. I've had some bad experiences in the past at other places, which, of course, makes me want to skip regular visits. But, at Cicero Family Dental, everyone is so kind, professional, and understanding. And it's a no judgement zone! If you have concerns/fears about going to the dentist, give them a try! You'll be glad you did.
Fantastic experience: Such a great dentist and staff!
Fantastic experience: We been going here for several years. The staff is always very kind. The Cicero site is very easy to get to and wheelchair friendly.
Fantastic experience: Excellent experience. The staff, techs and dentist really listen, explain everything clearly, and make sure there are no surprises. They make you feel comfortable and check in throughout procedures. The work is top-notch, and I truly appreciate the honesty and transparency. Highly recommend!
Fantastic experience: I always enjoy going to see Dr. Hartley and his staff. Everyone is always pleasant, concerned, and patient with any questions I might have. I would highly recommend Dr. Hartley for all your dental needs.!!
Fantastic experience: We always have great service for our dental care at Cicero Family Dental. Dr Hartley and his team go above and beyond to ensure our needs our meet.
Fantastic experience: Always a pleasure. Dr Hartley is a friendly knowledgeable dentist. His staff is always welcoming and efficient. They are able to use my insurance which is appreciated. A good experience. Thank you!
Fantastic experience: I was a patient of Dr Shields for years and I’m glad to say I’m a patient of Dr Hartley’s. He and his staff are always friendly and professional. I ask them tough questions concerning my care and the cost. They always answer them with transparency, therefore, I’m satisfied with the level of care I receive. My new review Nov 25, 2025. I continue my dental care with Doug Hartley at Cicero family dental because his office staff are always friendly and professional. I've had several times since my last review when I've needed care right away and he always fits me in to take care of my dental needs. He continues to educate himself and his staff to expand the scope of his capabilities and range of services. Because of that, I have every confidence in his ability to take care of our families dental needs.
Fantastic experience: I really enjoy going to the dentist. All the staff are so kind. They actually talk to you joke with you and make you feel a part of them. Dr. Hartley never condescends and complety explains that day's proceedure before AND during the process. I'm old and I've had many dentists throughout my life. I'd recommend the folks here to anyone. They also tell you up front, what the cost will be and do everything they can to save money! Check them out! I felt that their fees were very fair!
Fantastic experience: Staff and the dentist are always awesome at CFD. Very helpful with any questions that I have.
Fantastic experience: Love going to Cicero Family Dentistry. They are so very nice there. Wouldn't want to go anyplace else.
Fantastic experience: Love everything about Cicero Family Dental. From the front desk, Dental hygienist, Dental Assistance to the doctor. They are a great bunch of people who put my dental health first. Thank you all Great job I appreciate each one of you.
Fantastic experience: The staff are very friendly and caring.Highly recommend. They are always prompt with their service and have always done a great job for me.
Fantastic experience: Everyone is very friendly, costs are reasonable,. They explain everything and never sell!!
Fantastic experience: EXCELLENT customer care! The entire staff is kind and welcoming.
Fantastic experience: Great staff and very personable. I would recommend Cicero Family Dental. They’ve been my family’s dentist for over 15 years.
Fantastic experience: Had a tooth chip off and they scheduled an appointment the day I called and fixed it immediately.
Fantastic experience: The staff here are always friendly and welcoming.
Fantastic experience: My experience so far has been excellent
Fantastic experience: Friendly staff, on time, good experience.
Fantastic experience: So glad I made the switch to Cicero Family Dental. The staff is always so nice and welcoming.
Fantastic experience: Though I only had a cleaning, I had an excellent experience. Love the friendly & very helpful staff.
Fantastic experience: I LOVE Cicero family dental! My hygienist Amanda is the BEST! She is always extremely friendly and very gentle on my sensitive gums!
Fantastic experience: I absolutely LOVE the cicero family dental office! They were super quick and easy to make an appointment with. The staff are all super sweet and caring, and Dr. Hartley is truly amazing! Definitely recommend them 1000/10!!!!
Fantastic experience: Cicero Family Dental is amazing! I used to be Dr. Doug Hartley’s patient at his old office in Westfield. When I came in the Cicero location, they recognized me right away and greeted me warmly, it means so much to be remembered and welcomed, especially Kylie, who practically made it a celebration when she saw me. Dr. Hartley is kind, patient, and always chooses what’s best for me. His professionalism and experience really show in the quality of his work. Kylie is equally amazing, friendly, attentive, and highly skilled. She helps make every visit comfortable and smooth, and you can tell she is very well trained and cares about patients. The whole team greets everyone with big smiles, genuine kindness, and compliments that make you feel valued. I highly recommend them.
Fantastic experience: Everyone works hard for the best results! The doc tries his very best to make sure you’re comfortable!!
Fantastic experience: Office visits ran on time. Everyone was friendly. Dr explains in detail with pictures.
Fantastic experience: Felt like home not a dental office ,from Dr.Doug ,Kiely and front office very friendly and kind will recommend to anyone that wants a great smile
Fantastic experience: Dr. Doug and his team are amazing. I been here a few times but today I had to have a Root Canal done and Dr Doug and his assistant today Kia were fantastic. They made sure I was felt no pain while working on me and kept checking to make sure I was OK. I've never been to a place where they were so attentive and I really needed that.
Fantastic experience: Went in with extreme tenderness/pain at site of " bad " tooth. They were compassionate and gentle. Put me on an antibiotic with a plan of rescheduling an appointment once in a more comfortable state. No forced poking or prodding while I am this uncomfortable. Highly recommend!
Fantastic experience: I love the friendly staff. I have never liked going to the dentist but this group of people put me completely at ease. Kiely is the best!!!
Fantastic experience: Very pleasant experience! Very happy with my dentist appointment!
Fantastic experience: Awesome team....so professional and so caring! They move heaven and earth to make sure you feel like you're family.
Fantastic experience: Thank you Cicero Family Dental for your exceptional care. Dr. Hartley and his staff are very friendly and welcoming. I recommend this practice to anyone looking for a new dentist!
Fantastic experience: The girls and the dentist were very kind and understanding of my situation. They all treated well and I had a very good visit. Yes I would highly recommend them. Thanks for all your help today.
Fantastic experience: Always professional and like going to visit friends. Wonderful dental care
Fantastic experience: Wonderful dental practice, very caring and friendly! They all do such a great job of educating people. Highly recommend.
Fantastic experience: Amazing experience Im usually scared of the dentist but they made me feel at home and answered all my questions
Fantastic experience: I can’t recommend this practice enough! Dr. Hartley and his team provide exceptional quality care and genuinely prioritize patient comfort. I had significant dental work done in preparation for my upcoming wedding, and as someone who’s always struggled with dental anxiety, I was amazed by how calm and supported I felt throughout the process. Dr. Hartley was attentive, gentle, and always made sure I was comfortable before continuing. The entire staff is warm, professional, and truly treats you like family not just another patient. I’m so grateful for their care 10/10 experience!
Fantastic experience: dr. Doug and his assistant did a fantastic job in removing my temporary and replacing it with a gold crown
Fantastic experience: I am so impressed and pleased with everyone at Cicero Family Dental. Everyone is so kind and make you feel comfortable. Thank you so much. I am glad I have a great Dental practice.
Fantastic experience: I finally found my favorite dentist after 62 years…thank you Dr. Hartley! Friendliest staff you’ll ever meet! They are very thorough and do great work. State of the art equipment. Wish I would’ve found them years ago. You can’t go wrong.
Fantastic experience: Really like the family friendly atmosphere this office provides.
Fantastic experience: I just moved to the area and had first appointment for a potential issue. Everyone was very friendly and accommodating, once they realized I had an issue the moved my appt earlier. Dentist went over my current issue options and discussed other potential issues and the impact they would have. He spent much time with me and was not rushed. We now have a plan of attack.
Fantastic experience: I love going here everyone is always so friendly. Dr. Hartley does a great job along with all of his techs.
Fantastic experience: Love Dr. Doug and his associates! Thorough, professional and always fun! Great atmosphere.
Fantastic experience: By far the best experience I have ever had in a dentists office. All the staff is incredibly friendly and does a great job making people feel comfortable! Cannot say enough good things about Dr. Hartley and his staff
Fantastic experience: Great experience every cleaning. The staff is always so friendly!
Fantastic experience: Always kind, courteous, and very knowledgeable in what they do. Il
Fantastic experience: My experience at Hartley dental was awesome
Fantastic experience: I've been going to Cicero family dentistry for at least a decade now and every time I feel like I'm arriving to a family members house because everyone there makes me feel so welcome!
Fantastic experience: When we moved back to Indiana after so many years away one thing I dread is finding a new dentist. Cicero Dental and Dr Doug made it a positive move and I loved my prior dentist in AZ. Thorough, communicate well and always looking for best option for their patients, not just a cookie-cutter approach.
Fantastic experience: Felt like a very friendly place. Kai made me feel comfortable and Dr. did a great job of communicating what he was going to do and doing. For a guy who hates going to the dentist, I came away very satisfied. Thanks!
Fantastic experience: What great experience today at my new patient visit! The staff members and provider were very friendly and helpful! Looking forward to making Cicero Family Dental my new provider for all my dental needs!! Thank you so much :)
Fantastic experience: I came to discuss a comprehensive treatment plan with Dr Hartley. He gave me several options. He showed me what the options would look like. He answered all my questions. He took his time with me and listened to me. Highly recommend him for your dental needs
Fantastic experience: Dr Hartley and his staff are very knowledgeable. They always make sure the patients are comfortable and understand the procedures. A quote is given upfront so you know what you will pay! I highly recommend cicero family dental. Thank you dr. Hartley and staff!
Fantastic experience: Staff was great and Dr Doug is in a class all his own!!
Fantastic experience: Thank you to Amanda and Dr Doug! Great experience as a first time patient to this practice.
Fantastic experience: I'm a new patient and found that they are Very friendly, nice atmosphere. Definitely would recommend.
Fantastic experience: Cicero Family Dental is a very warm and caring office. The dental assistants, hygienists and staff are very helpful and meet you with a smile. Dr. Doug is an A+ dentist. He is very gentle and thorough and is always ready to answer any questions or concerns I have. The atmosphere there is definitely one of “family.” I never feel like I’m just an “ Account number” but that I am truly cared about. I would highly recommend dr. Doug and Cicero Family Dental!
Fantastic experience: Another cleaning today, everyone was very focused and helpful - five stars for Dr. Doug and his entire staff! Jennifer did a superb cleaning of my teeth, very attentive and always explains everything she does.
Fantastic experience: A great experience! Professional, fun staff that are so competent!
Fantastic experience: Love Dr Hartley and his staff. They always do a great job, and let you know if you need any further dental work. Leslie is so good checking your insurance to be sure you get all the covered benefits. Highly recommend Dr Hartley
Fantastic experience: Best cleaning I've had in several years! Office is super clean and staff was so personable!
Fantastic experience: The staff was very helpful and friendly. They were right on time and I was in and out within an hour. Dr. Hartley was friendly and informative.
Fantastic experience: Called them because I ended up losing a filling & they got me in same day and were able to get me all fixed up. Very friendly staff as well, I usually hate dentists but they made me feel comfortable! I would definitely recommend them.
Negative experience: I hope you can get an appointment for a cleaning sooner than I was told ; they are 3 to 6 months out for scheduling those appointments. I just moved here and needed an appointment sooner and wasn’t even offered to be put on a call list. Was told I may find the wait from most dentists but did not. I was so excited to try a dental office with great reviews but couldn’t get in . I hope others can be accommodated.
Fantastic experience: Very pleasant for a dental appointment. I have always feared even since childhood. Thank u
Fantastic experience: Very happy with work and service. Dr Hartley has a very kind warm and friendly demeanor. I have now been to office 3 times for work as well as my teens had work there as well. Staff is great too.
Fantastic experience: Dr. Hartley and his team are phenomenal! My Maw felt so comfortable there and couldn’t stop bragging about how much she loves them and it’s the best dentist she’s ever been to! It’s clear that Dr. Hartley and his team genuinely care for their patients and treat them like family!
Fantastic experience: Best experience great sense of humor and I never felt a thing
Fantastic experience: Great office, hard working and friendly staff and dentist!
Fantastic experience: Highly recommend. Friendly and efficient. Jennifer was great.
Fantastic experience: I will never go anywhere else. Exceptional staff and they make the experience a delight!
Fantastic experience: A very pleasant visit from the staff, the Technician, and most of all Dr.Doug's Associate. It is always a pleasant visit. Thank-you
Fantastic experience: Jen was very kind and helpful, she cleaned my teeth and got me out the door when I was in a hurry to make it to another appointment. The staff is very friendly and accommodating. Thank you!
Fantastic experience: Fast cleaning today-thank you for getting me to my next “to do list item”. You make teeth cleaning as enjoyable as it can be!
Fantastic experience: Great office and fast service. I appreciate how they try to work you in when you forget to make an appt! Great energy!
Fantastic experience: Cicero Family Dental truly cares about their patients. From the time you check in and until you walk out the door you are treated as family. A very relaxed atmosphere that understands the needs of their patients. I would recommend Cicero Family Dental to anyone! Dr.Hartley is first class.
Fantastic experience: It is always a great experience at Cicero family dental! They put you at ease and everyone is so friendly! Dr. Doug is awesome and hygienist Jennifer is wonderful and pays a lot of attention to every detail!
Fantastic experience: My cleaning was quick and painless. Amanda is friendly and gentle.
Fantastic experience: Staff is amazing! Dr Hartley explained in detail procedures and the “why” behind it! Love this practice! First visit! Highly recommend!
Fantastic experience: ⚓️ i’ve had a lot of good dentist over the years, but this outfit tops them all. Great doctor good staff. Always taken care of all my needs. Have never turned me away.
Fantastic experience: Always great service. Very professional. Clearly explain treatment options and alternatives.
Fantastic experience: I love this dentist office. They are always helpful really fun and do an amazing job. I love coming here. They even helped me with my kids so I could keep my appointment. They're definitely a god send.
Fantastic experience: I have my teeth cleaned twice a year. Everyone is always very friendly and they all take extra care to make me feel special. I feel like part of a family, instead of just another customer!
Fantastic experience: This visit was for a check up and cleaning. Everyone in the office is friendly and nice. The hygienist always does a great job; she is gentle and quick. She and Dr. Hartley are very good at educating and explaining things.
Leave your review about Cicero Family Dental:
Cicero Family Dental appears in the following listings:
Other dentists you might be interested in
Add your business to our directory for free
If you have a dental clinic and want to appear in our guide, send us your business information and you can appear completely free of charge.